In the advanced gear calculation, the stress is determined using the influence coefficient method. In this process, the load distribution is calculated based on a simplified stiffness matrix and the local gape distance between the tooth flanks. The accuracy of the load distribution calculation is directly dependent on the quality of the stiffness matrix. The following methods can be used for calculating tooth stiffness, depending on the scope of the calculation and model:
- BEM influence coefficient: BEM influence coefficient method
The tooth stiffness is calculated using the 2D BEM method. The tooth deformation is determined numerically via a reference value at the force application point. It uses approximated, generalized influence functions for coupling the 2D sections to deliver fast and sufficiently accurate stiffness values for bevel and hypoid gears. The linear deformation components due to bending, thrust, and pressure are taken into account, as is the non-linear contact deformation, which is iterated depending on the force. The resilience of the wheel body is approximated by linking the tooth geometry to an elastic half-space. This corresponds to a good approximation of a standard wheel body.
Advantages: proven method, validated in practice, short calculation time
Disadvantages: deformation of the wheel gear body in axial direction is neglected, torsion of the pinion is neglected, tooth root stresses are only determined as maximum stresses per width section
- BEM influence coefficient with FEM wheel body: combination of BEM and FEM influence coefficients for the wheel body
This corresponds to the BEM influence coefficient method, but the highly simplified wheel body is replaced with a detailed FEM wheel body. The deformation of the wheel body is calculated using FEM influence coefficients. The FEM method also makes it possible to consider the coupling influences between the meshing teeth. This calculation method requires an FEM model of the wheel body. The wheel body is selected, designed, and activated as a bevel gear wheel body component and is assigned to the corresponding bevel gear.
Advantages: effect of the wheel body on the tooth stiffness is included, supports modeling of the wheel body with configurable standard wheel bodies as well as integration of CAD wheel bodies
Disadvantages: increased modeling effort and calculation time
- FEM influence coefficient: FEM influence coefficient method
The tooth deformation is calculated with FEM influence coefficients, and therefore the approximated, generalized influence functions of the BEM method are no longer required. This method enables detailed consideration of the interactions with the wheel body. Thus, the wheel body should be configured in the bevel gear wheel body component for the calculation with FEM influence coefficients. The FEM method requires analysis of the mesh discretization (convergence analysis). This method offers the highest level of detail in the deformation calculation, but high calculation times are to be expected. Evaluation of the operating backlash and the 3D tooth root stress are also available.
Advantages: Results close to FEM results, 3D tooth root stresses and safeties, operating backlash calculation possible.
Disadvantages: requires fine FEM mesh, high computing time, convergence analysis recommended
| |
Advanced gear calculation |
| |
without wheel body |
with wheel body |
operating backlash calculation |
3D tooth root stress |
| BEM influence coefficient |
Standard method |
- |
- |
- |
| BEM influence coefficient with FEM wheel body |
- |
Standard method |
- |
- |
| FEM influence coefficient |
Expert method |
Expert method |
Standard method |
Standard method |